By selecting "Accept all", you give us permission to use the following services on our website: Strictly necessary cookies, YouTube, Vimeo, ReCaptcha, Google Analytics, Google Ads, Google Tag Manager, Brevo, Meta Pixel, PayPal Express Checkout und Ratenzahlung. You can change the settings at any time (fingerprint icon in the bottom left corner). For further details, please see Individual configuration and our Privacy notice.
The settings you specify here are stored in the "local storage" of your device. The settings will be remembered for the next time you visit our online shop. You can change these settings at any time (fingerprint icon in the bottom left corner).
For more information on cookie lifetime and required essential cookies, please see the Privacy notice.
To view YouTube contents on this website,
you need to consent to the transfer of data and storage of third-party cookies by
YouTube (Google).
This allows us to improve your user experience and to make our
website better and more interesting.
Without your consent, no data will be transferred to YouTube.
However, you will also not be able to use the YouTube services on this website.
To view Vimeo contents on this website, you need to consent to the
transfer of data and storage of third-party cookies by Vimeo..
This allows us to improve your user
experience and to make our website better and more interesting.
Without your consent, no data will
be transferred to Vimeo. However, you will also not be able to use the Vimdeo services on this website.
To submit forms on this page, you need to consent to the transfer of data and storage of third-party cookies by Google.
With your consent, reCAPTCHA, a Google service to avoid spam messages via contact forms, will be embedded.
This service allows us to provide our customers with a safe way to contact us via online forms. At the same time, the service prevents spam bots from compromising our services.
After you gave your permission, you might be asked to answer a security prompt to send the form.
If you do not consent, unfortunately you cannot use the form. Please contact us in a different way.
This is a web analysis service. It allows the user to measure advertising return on investment (ROI) and track user behavior. Data collected: anonymized IP address, date and time of visit, usage data, click path, app updates, browser information, device information, JavaScript support, pages visited, referrer URL, location information, purchase activity, widget interactions.
This is an advertising service. This service can be used to display personalized or non-personalized advertising to users. With Google Ads Conversion Tracking, we can measure our advertising success in the Google advertising network. We place advertisements in the Google advertising network so that our offers can be found more easily. We try to optimize our advertising as much as possible. Also to keep advertising costs as low as possible. This is reflected in our prices.
This is a tag management system. The Google Tag Manager allows tags to be integrated centrally via a user interface. Tags are small sections of code that can track activities. Script codes from other tools are integrated via the Google Tag Manager. The Tag Manager makes it possible to control when a specific tag is triggered.
To send data to Brevo, you need to consent to the transfer of data and storage of third-party cookies by Brevo. This allows us to improve your user experience and to make our website better and more interesting.
To send data to Meta, you need to consent to the transfer of data and storage of third-party cookies by Meta.. This allows us to improve your user experience and to make our website better and more interesting.
In order to unlock offers for extended payment options, in particular express checkout and payment in instalments, we require your consent to the data transfer and storage of third-party cookies of the payment provider PayPal. This allows us to also offer you express checkout and payment by instalments. Without your consent, only the technically necessary data transfer to PayPal will take place, but you will then not be able to use the express checkout or extended offers for payment by instalments on this site.
Description:
Using express checkout and Displaying offers for payment in instalments for individual items or your entire purchase.
Would you like to see these contents? Activate the desired contents for one session only or allow the website to remember these settings. Once you have given your consent, the third-party data can be loaded. For this, third-party cookies might be stored on your device. You can change these settings at any time (fingerprint icon in the bottom left corner). For further details, please see the Privacy notice.
By Andreas | Viterna.atUpdated November 202611 min read
For the same number of calories, boiled potatoes are around seven times as filling as a croissant. A research team in Sydney measured this back in 1995. And yet the potato still has a reputation for being fattening.
When it comes to losing weight, opinions outnumber measurements. Yet over the past decades researchers have looked remarkably closely at what fills us up, why sleep changes hunger and why the body barely registers what we drink.
Here you can read which of it stands up to scientific scrutiny, which statements on weight the EU has assessed and which products in our range suit which purpose. With figures instead of promises.
Symbolic image: AI-generated
Energy balance: where your body spends its energy
In the long run your weight follows a simple sum: the energy you eat and drink against the energy you use. This is called energy balance. The interesting part is the spending side, because it is made up of several items. The largest is your resting energy use, the energy for breathing, heartbeat and body heat. Then come digestion and movement, and movement splits into daily life and exercise.
Digestion costs energy too. Scientists call it the thermic effect of food. How much it costs depends heavily on what is on your plate. Of every 100 calories from protein, 20 to 30 are spent on processing alone. Of every 100 calories from fat, it is 3 at most.
20 to 30%
of the energy in protein is needed just to process it
5 to 15%
is the figure for carbohydrates
0 to 3%
is the figure for fat
5 to 15%
of daily energy use goes on digestion with a mixed diet
Did you know? In a famous experiment from 1999, 16 volunteers were given 1,000 calories more than they needed every day. Some stored ten times as much fat as others. The difference was not explained by sport but by everyday movement: standing, walking, pottering about, fidgeting. Researchers call it NEAT.
One more thing worth knowing: your body keeps its own accounts. As you get lighter, you also use a little less energy. That is normal and not a sign that something is wrong. Rigid formulas from the internet ignore this, which is why they often promise too much.
Potato beats croissant: what really fills you up
In 1995 the Australian researcher Susanna Holt asked volunteers to eat 38 different foods, always in portions of exactly 240 calories. For two hours afterwards she recorded how full they felt. White bread was given the reference value of 100. The result became known as the satiety index: boiled potatoes came top with 323, the croissant came last with 47.
Three years later the American researcher Barbara Rolls showed why. In her experiment 18 women ate freely on several days from dishes with low, medium or high energy density. Each time they ate roughly the same weight of food. In other words, we tend to eat by volume rather than by calories.
Symbolic image: AI-generated
Boiled potatoes
satiety index, highest value
323
White bread
reference value
100
Croissant
lowest value
47
Dishes rich in water
a day, same amount of food
1,376 kcal
Energy-dense dishes
a day, equally full
1,800 kcal
Energy density means calories per gram. Vegetables, fruit, soups, potatoes and pulses contain plenty of water and fibre and deliver few calories per bite. For the women in the experiment that added up to roughly a quarter fewer calories, and they felt just as full. In a later, longer study the group eating more fruit and vegetables actually ate a greater weight of food and reported less hunger.
For everyday life: You do not have to eat less, just fill your plate differently. A vegetable soup as a starter, half the plate for vegetables or salad, and boiled potatoes instead of chips change the energy density of a meal considerably.
What the EU confirms
The EU assesses health claims for foods very strictly. On the subject of weight, only two groups have passed: the dietary fibre glucomannan from the konjac root, and meal replacements for weight control. Both statements apply expressly only in the context of an energy-restricted diet. Here is the exact wording:
Glucomannan in the context of an energy restricted diet contributes to weight loss.
Substituting two of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with meal replacements contributes to weight loss.
Substituting one of the main daily meals of an energy restricted diet with a meal replacement contributes to the maintenance of weight after weight loss.
Condition for glucomannan: The beneficial effect is obtained with a daily intake of 3 g of glucomannan in three doses of 1 g each, together with 1 to 2 glasses of water, before meals and in the context of an energy-restricted diet. Warning: there is a risk of choking for people with swallowing difficulties or when taken with inadequate fluid. Always take glucomannan with plenty of water so that it reaches the stomach.
The EU also specifies exactly what a meal replacement must contain: 200 to 250 calories per meal, at least a quarter and at most half of the energy from protein, no more than 30% from fat, plus vitamins and minerals. An adequate daily fluid intake matters, and so does the setting: such products are useful only as part of an energy-restricted diet in which other foods are a necessary part. For the first statement, two main meals a day should be replaced, for the second, one.
Nutrients around metabolism and muscles
There are also authorised claims that do not concern weight but fit the topic well. They apply to products that supply enough of the nutrient in question:
Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass.
Chromium contributes to normal macronutrient metabolism.
Chromium contributes to the maintenance of normal blood glucose levels.
Zinc contributes to normal carbohydrate metabolism.
Thiamine (vitamin B1) contributes to normal energy-yielding metabolism.
Vitamin B12 contributes to normal energy-yielding metabolism.
Macronutrients are the three main sources of energy: carbohydrates, fat and protein. By the way: in the EU, manufacturers are generally not allowed to state how much or how fast someone loses weight with a food. That is why you will not find any promises in kilos here.
Eight everyday tips that stand up to science
The six tips from our earlier post have become eight, each with a source behind it. None of them is a diet. They are small adjustments to eating, drinking, sleep and movement.
1
Fill up on foods rich in water
Vegetables, salad, soups, fruit, potatoes and pulses fill the plate with few calories per bite. In the experiment by Barbara Rolls, participants felt just as full as with energy-dense food.
2
Plan protein into every meal
The German Nutrition Society (DGE) gives 0.8 g of protein per kg of body weight a day, and 1.0 g from the age of 65. The research literature on weight management mentions 1.2 to 1.6 g per kg and about 25 to 30 g per meal. Good sources are quark, yoghurt, eggs, fish, pulses and tofu.
3
Aim for 30 g of fibre a day
This is the DGE guideline for adults. Wholemeal bread, oats, pulses, vegetables, berries and nuts get you there. Increase the amount slowly and drink enough with it.
4
Do not drink your calories
In one study participants were given 450 calories a day either as a soft drink or as jelly beans. They made up for the sweets by eating less elsewhere, but not for the drink. The DGE recommends around 1.5 litres a day, ideally water or unsweetened tea.
5
Give sleep its place
After two nights with only four hours in bed, the hunger hormone ghrelin rose by 28% and hunger by 24% in one experiment. Conversely, short sleepers who slept about 1.2 hours longer ate 270 calories less a day on average, without any dietary instructions.
6
Move more in daily life
In one study, lean people with a sedentary lifestyle were on their feet around two hours longer each day than the comparison group. Walking while on the phone, stairs instead of the lift, getting off one stop early: it all adds up. For steps, the benefit for health levels off somewhere between 6,000 and 10,000 a day, depending on age.
7
Challenge your muscles
Eating less means losing not only fat but muscle too. Strength training counteracts this: in six studies with older adults it preserved almost all of their fat-free mass. Two to three sessions a week with dumbbells, bands or your own body weight are a good start.
8
Cook from scratch more often
In a tightly controlled trial by the US National Institutes of Health, 20 adults ate 508 calories more a day on an ultra-processed diet than on an unprocessed one, although both menus offered the same calories, sugar, fat and fibre.
What else research shows
A huge amount of research is done on weight, from small laboratory trials with a dozen volunteers to analyses covering tens of thousands of people. Two findings run through many of the papers.
Exercise is valuable, but it does not replace what you eat. In an analysis of 14 studies with 1,847 people, the authors called the contribution of aerobic exercise alone “modest”. One reason: the body compensates for part of it. Measurements in 332 adults from five countries showed that daily energy use levels off in very active people. In large reviews, the combination of strength training and an adjusted diet comes out best.
Muscles need attention. According to one review, when people lose weight through diet alone, about 20 to 30% of it is fat-free mass, which includes muscle. Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass, but more strength only comes from training.
Our view: Many of the trials are small and short, so the figures should be read as orders of magnitude, not as guarantees. The picture is consistent all the same: eat your fill with low energy density, get enough protein, sleep well, keep moving through the day and do some strength training. Food supplements can accompany this but cannot replace it.
Glucomannan, shake, protein, nutrients: what suits you?
Very different products sit side by side on the shelf. Here is what is behind them:
Glucomannan
dietary fibre
A dietary fibre from the konjac root that swells considerably in water. You take the capsules before meals with plenty of water. For you if you want to accompany your energy-restricted diet with a fibre that has an EU statement on weight.
Meal replacement
instead of a meal
A shake that replaces a main meal. The EU lays down calories, protein share, vitamins and minerals precisely. For you if you want one or two meals a day to be fixed and uncomplicated.
Protein powder
for your muscles
Concentrated protein from pea, rice, milk or egg. Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass. For you if food alone does not get you to your protein target or you need something quick after training.
Metabolism nutrients
chromium, zinc, B vitamins
Chromium, zinc and B vitamins are involved in how the body uses carbohydrates, fat and protein. For you if you are eating less and still want to be well supplied with these nutrients.
Then there are pure fibre powders such as psyllium husk or acacia fibre. They help you reach the guideline of 30 g of fibre a day. You will find flavoured protein powders in the protein powder category and all products on this topic in the weight management category.
Our recommendations
Four products for four approaches: glucomannan before meals, a vegan shake, an unflavoured protein powder and a capsule with zinc and B vitamins.
Ideal for: anyone who wants to accompany an energy-restricted diet with glucomannan: 1 g per dose, three times a day before a meal, each time with 2 glasses of water
Glucomannan in the context of an energy restricted diet contributes to weight loss. The beneficial effect is obtained with a daily intake of 3 g of glucomannan in three doses of 1 g each, together with 1 to 2 glasses of water, before meals and in the context of an energy-restricted diet. Warning: risk of choking for people with swallowing difficulties or when taken with inadequate fluid, so take with plenty of water. Chromium and zinc contribute to normal macronutrient metabolism. Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass. Thiamine contributes to normal energy-yielding metabolism.
Amounts per daily dose or serving as stated by the manufacturer. Najara: values for the prepared shake made from 40 g of powder, 175 ml of rice drink and 5 drops of rapeseed oil. You will find the exact directions for use on each product page.
Fact: What counts is the total over the whole day, not so much the time. In a study with 78 police officers, the group that ate most of its carbohydrates in the evening did no worse than the comparison group on the same number of calories. It is a single study, but it takes the edge off the rule.
Myth 2
“Fat makes you fat.”
Fact: At 9 calories per gram, fat has the highest energy density, while carbohydrates and protein come in at 4. That does not make low-fat automatically better: in a Stanford University study with 609 adults there was no meaningful difference between a healthy low-fat and a healthy low-carb diet. Total amount and quality are what matter.
Myth 3
“Exercise alone is enough.”
Fact: Movement is very valuable for heart, circulation and muscles and helps to keep a weight stable. As the only measure, however, aerobic exercise achieves little according to studies, because the body compensates for part of it. A croissant is eaten faster than it is walked off.
Myth 4
“With the right capsule the fat melts away by itself.”
Fact: No capsule replaces energy balance. On weight, the EU has assessed and authorised exactly two statements: for glucomannan and for meal replacements, both only in the context of an energy-restricted diet.
Good to know when using these products
✓
Always take glucomannan with plenty of water
Take the capsules 30 to 45 minutes before a meal with two glasses of water. They are not suitable for people with swallowing difficulties. Pregnant and breastfeeding women should clarify use beforehand.
✓
Do not double up on chromium
The Slim Caps already contain 40 µg of chromium a day. Do not combine them with an additional chromium supplement. Stick to one product.
✓
Keep an eye on caffeine and synephrine
Optiolex Crematio contains 4.8 mg of caffeine from guarana and 3 mg of synephrine from bitter orange per capsule. Stay with one capsule a day and take it with plenty of liquid.
✓
Allergens in protein powders
nutri+ 6K contains soy, wheat and almonds. Aktiv3 Protein XXL 92 contains milk, egg and soy. Never take fibre powders such as psyllium husk dry, and leave an hour between them and any medication.
The comparison of the energy you take in with the energy you use. Energy use consists of resting energy use, digestion and movement in daily life and exercise.
Which foods are particularly filling?+
In the satiety index of 1995, boiled potatoes came top with a value of 323, white bread served as the reference with 100, and the croissant scored 47.
What is glucomannan?+
A soluble dietary fibre from the tuber of the konjac plant. It swells considerably in water. Glucomannan in the context of an energy restricted diet contributes to weight loss when 3 g are taken daily in three doses of 1 g each with 1 to 2 glasses of water before meals. There is a risk of choking for people with swallowing difficulties or when taken with too little fluid.
How do I take glucomannan capsules correctly?+
With nutri+ Slim Caps, take 2 capsules three times a day, each time 30 to 45 minutes before a meal with 2 glasses of water. That makes 3 g of glucomannan a day.
How much protein do I need a day?+
The DGE reference value is 0.8 g per kg of body weight, and 1.0 g from the age of 65. The research literature on weight management mentions 1.2 to 1.6 g per kg. Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass.
How much fibre should I eat?+
The DGE gives at least 30 g a day for adults. Whole grains, pulses, vegetables, fruit and nuts are the best sources.
Do I have to walk 10,000 steps a day?+
No, the number is not a scientific threshold. In an analysis of 15 studies, the benefit for health levelled off at about 6,000 to 8,000 steps for people over 60 and at 8,000 to 10,000 for younger adults. Every extra step counts.
Why is strength training useful when losing weight?+
If you eat less, you lose muscle as well as fat. Strength training signals to the body that the muscles are needed. Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass.
In a nutshell
Losing weight is not about the one right capsule but about many small adjustments: eating your fill with low energy density, enough protein and fibre, water instead of soft drinks, good sleep and movement in daily life. If you would like a product to go with it, choose by what the EU confirms.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Boiled potatoes scored 323 in the satiety index, the croissant 47.
Protein costs the body 20 to 30% of its energy to process, fat only 0 to 3%.
On weight, the EU has authorised two statements: for glucomannan and for meal replacements, each in the context of an energy-restricted diet.
Protein contributes to the maintenance of muscle mass, and strength training gives the muscles the stimulus.
More knowledge by email
New guides, facts and tips, straight to your inbox.
Note: This article is for general information only. Food supplements are not a substitute for a varied, balanced diet and a healthy lifestyle. Do not exceed the recommended daily intake. Keep out of the reach of young children. Sources include: Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006, Regulation (EU) No 432/2012 and 2016/1413, DGE reference values for protein and dietary fibre, Holt et al. (1995), Bell et al. (1998), Ello-Martin et al. (2007), Westerterp (2004), Levine et al. (1999, 2005), Leidy et al. (2015), Cava et al. (2017), Spiegel et al. (2004), Tasali et al. (2022), DiMeglio and Mattes (2000), Hall et al. (2019), Paluch et al. (2022), Thorogood et al. (2011), Pontzer et al. (2016), Sardeli et al. (2018), Gardner et al. (2018), Sofer et al. (2011), ACSM (2009).